Deena, I have to tell you this! Just offered Ralph the Dog a store-bought treat someone gave me. He looked at it and walked away. Then I offered him a Flint River Ranch biscuit. That one he gladly took.  Took him to a new vet the other day who asked if he had had his teeth cleaned recently. I’ve never had them cleaned in the 3 years+ that I’ve had him. Don’t look like they need it. What’s more, no one can believe he’s 14. Must be the food!